Home Sports NFL All-Underrated Team 2021 - Barnwell's 24-player roster of vets, rookies, draft...

NFL All-Underrated Team 2021 – Barnwell’s 24-player roster of vets, rookies, draft steals and free-agency finds

Today, I’m naming my All-Underrated Team for what we have seen to date within the 2021 NFL season. Last time we did this in 2019, I talked up gamers corresponding to Matthew Judon, Austin Ekeler, Vita Vea, Fred Warner and others who’ve emerged with bigger profiles over the following two seasons. Hopefully, we’ll see the profiles of the gamers on this yr’s listing develop equally within the years to return.

Of course, “underrated” is within the eye of the beholder. I believe that almost everybody who reads this listing could have a participant or two they suppose of as underrated who is not going to look among the many 24 gamers right here. In most instances, I believe the one distinction is simply that I believe these gamers are already given lots of consideration as priceless contributors. Some guidelines I labored with in placing this listing collectively embrace:

  • Have you performed on the similar degree for a protracted interval of time? Veterans corresponding to Andrew Whitworth or Micah Hyde have been “underrated” for therefore lengthy that they are appropriately rated now as wonderful soccer gamers. This listing tends to level out youthful gamers and/or gamers who’ve modified their degree of play versus what we have seen in years previous, which incorporates the group’s solely quarterback.

  • Were you a primary-spherical decide? If you are a primary-rounder in your rookie deal, you are usually going to be anticipated to play at a excessive degree. There’s a primary-rounder who makes it onto the roster right here as a result of he has emerged as one of the very best gamers at his place and does not typically get talked about in that dialog. A high-5 decide corresponding to Ja’Marr Chase or Nick Bosa is not actually underrated.

  • Have you been paid? If you racked up a giant deal in free company or out of your group, you are already valued as a big participant at your place. Trey Hendrickson was underrated (by me and others) heading into this season, and he has been wonderful for the Bengals, however he is additionally taking dwelling $20 million, which tells you that he is already being handled as a priceless participant. Most of the gamers listed below are on both rookie offers or contracts under their market worth. One participant simply obtained a brand new deal, so I’m dishonest a bit by sneaking him onto the listing.

With that in thoughts, let’s run by way of our group. We have 24 gamers from 15 totally different organizations, with a deal with making an attempt to get in guys from some of the worst groups. We’ll begin on the offensive aspect of the ball and then work our method by way of the protection and particular groups, starting with a participant who surprisingly ranked within the high 10 at his place earlier than struggling a season-ending damage:

Jump to a place:
QB | RB | WR | TE
OT | G | C | K | P
EDGE | DT | LB | CB | S


Yes, we’re beginning with a participant who’s done for the season with a torn ACL, but it surely’s just about not possible to be underrated as a quarterback. Winston qualifies. Across his seven video games this season, his 64.3 Total QBR ranks fifth within the league, nestled between Aaron Rodgers and Kyler Murray. Don’t need to use QBR? Winston ranks seventh in passer ranking and adjusted yards per try. For a man who could not cease throwing interceptions in Tampa Bay, he posted a 14-to-3 landing-to-interception ratio throughout his seven 2021 begins.

If you need to give some of the credit score for Winston’s enchancment to Sean Payton and the Saints’ offensive line, that is tremendous. You even have to present Winston credit score for succeeding with a principally nameless group of receivers. The 2015 No. 1 total decide had Alvin Kamara, however he was in any other case throwing to Marquez Callaway, Deonte Harris, Adam Trautman and Juwan Johnson. At the very least, Winston — a free agent in 2022 — did sufficient to earn a repeat alternative with the Saints subsequent season.

Most everybody acknowledges that Robinson is an honest again, however he has a Pro Bowl résumé as a runner this season. Playing in an offense with a passing sport that may charitably be described as inconsistent, he has run 112 instances for 568 yards, averaging 5.1 yards per clip. You would possibly chalk that as much as defenses not caring concerning the run, however DVOA adjusts for sport rating and state of affairs, and his 31.4% DVOA is the league’s best among regular backs.

Advanced metrics recommend that Robinson will get greater than what’s blocked. He’s averaging 2.2 yards after first contact this season, which ranks fourth amongst runners with at the very least 100 carries. By the NFL Next Gen Stats, he has generated 66 yards greater than a mean again would have picked up on the identical carries, which ranks fifth on a per-run foundation and forward of guys corresponding to Dalvin Cook, Derrick Henry and Ezekiel Elliott.

Robinson does not provide a lot as a receiver, however he is an excellent younger participant on a group with out many of them.

I do not suppose you possibly can actually make this listing with out Patterson on the roster someplace. There’s nobody within the league fairly like Patterson, who has been the very best kickoff returner in soccer over the previous decade and served as every thing from a cut up-out receiver to an I-formation working again. But not even his household may have anticipated what he would do in his first season with Atlanta.

Patterson’s main position is as a working again, however the 30-yr-outdated has been the point of interest of Matt Ryan‘s passing assault when he is been on the sector. He has been focused on 33.3% of the routes he has run this season, making him the league’s second-most ceaselessly focused participant behind Christian McCaffrey. The 4-time Pro Bowl returner has then averaged 9.9 yards per goal, which ranks forward of all different backs and would rank thirteenth amongst receivers.

Patterson additionally scored seven touchdowns on 116 touches earlier than suffering an ankle injury, which price him a revenge sport in opposition to his former New England group. It in all probability should not be a shock that the Falcons melted down with out him; Ryan has an 81.4 QBR with Patterson on the sector and a 29.5 QBR with out him. I do not know the way lengthy Patterson can preserve this up, but it surely has been enjoyable to observe.

A participant I’m sneaking onto this listing simply after he signed a three-year, $34 million extension with the Broncos earlier this month, Patrick has justified maintaining a snap fee topping 90% most weeks within the lineup, even after Jerry Jeudy‘s return. Here are the stats for 2 receivers because the begin of 2020:

Player A is Patrick. Player B is Deebo Samuel. The 49ers star is the higher participant, having carried out this on fewer routes and providing extra as a runner, however Samuel is a a lot increased-profile participant, and their numbers are just about similar.

Patrick ranks fourth in receiving DVOA this season and is averaging 9.9 yards per goal whereas enjoying with Teddy Bridgewater as his quarterback. He averaged 9.4 yards per goal final season whereas catching passes from Drew Lock, Jeff Driskel, Brett Rypien and Kendall Hinton. Patrick does not entice the kind of goal share celebrity wideouts see, however he is one of essentially the most environment friendly wideouts within the league.

The Patriots’ free-agent shopping spree at receiver has yielded a blended bag of outcomes. Nelson Agholor and Jonnu Smith have not been spectacular given their salaries, however Hunter Henry has been a purple zone risk and Bourne has been a particularly efficient second receiver possibility behind Jakobi Meyers. You’ve in all probability seen lots of Bourne’s two spotlight-reel performs, provided that they featured him splitting between Damontae Kazee and Trevon Diggs for a 75-yard touchdown and a spectacular leaping catch for a rating in opposition to the Browns.

Those performs aren’t essentially typical of his week-to-week position within the offense, however the former 49ers wideout has caught greater than 78% of his targets this season. NFL Next Gen Stats has his anticipated catch fee at 67.4%, that means he is working at almost 11% above expectation. That’s the third-greatest mark within the league, behind solely these of Christian Kirk and Patrick.

Some of the hype surrounding the Patriots’ offense is overstated, provided that they rank sixteenth in offensive and passing DVOA, however Bourne has outplayed his three-year, $15 million deal.

Uzomah isn’t going to be the point of interest of an offense with Ja’Marr Chase, Joe Mixon and Tee Higgins within the combine, however the 28-yr-outdated takes benefit when he does get alternatives. Coming off a torn Achilles, he has caught 27 of the 31 passes thrown in his path this season for an 87.1% catch fee. He ranks second in catch fee and catch fee over expectation behind Broncos tight finish Albert Okwuegbunam. Both gamers catch shorter passes than most of their tight finish brethren, however Uzomah sees the ball extra ceaselessly, averaging a exceptional 10.4 yards per goal. He additionally chips in as a really stable run-blocker.

In the ultimate yr of his deal, Uzomah has earned a significant increase from the $5 million or so he’ll earn in 2021.

Forced into responsibility for the Cowboys in 2020 after La’el Collins missed your entire season with a hip damage, Steele struggled early in his rookie season however improved because the yr went on. The Cowboys had been excited to welcome again Collins for 2021, however when Collins was suspended for five games, Steele moved again into the lineup. This time, the previous undrafted free agent saved the job.

Steele has been excellent in an each-down position, first for granted deal with and lately filling in for Tyron Smith as a left deal with. Excellent swing tackles get about $10 million per yr on the open market; the Cowboys pays Steele lower than $6 million for the subsequent three seasons. He’s one of essentially the most quietly priceless gamers within the league.

Here’s one other participant pressured into motion by damage. Ronnie Stanley‘s ankle points meant Alejandro Villanueva wanted to maneuver again to left deal with, opening up a spot on the appropriate aspect for Mekari, who had spent most of his time with the Ravens at heart.

Mekari was so good over his first six starts that John Harbaugh known as his utility lineman’s play “spectacular.” He suffered a excessive ankle sprain and missed a month earlier than returning for Sunday’s win over the Bears. Mekari is one of the numerous gamers maintaining an damage-riddled Ravens lineup afloat within the AFC North.

In some ways, Hurst was Mekari’s predecessor in Baltimore as a utility lineman. Having moved to New Orleans in 2020, Hurst has began video games this season at left deal with, left guard and most lately proper deal with for an damage-hit Saints line. He has been nice nearly in every single place, permitting simply one half-sack throughout 500 offensive snaps.

I’m dishonest a bit by working him out right here at guard when he has performed extra deal with in 2021, however as soon as the Saints get their star tackles again, he’ll in all probability end the season at left guard.

An instantaneous pressure after being drafted within the sixth spherical in April, Smith took over the appropriate guard job in coaching camp and hasn’t seemed again since. Kansas City was glad sufficient with Smith’s play to trade veteran Laurent Duvernay-Tardif to the Jets earlier than the commerce deadline.

Smith fell within the draft over considerations about his well being after coping with blood clots in his lungs, however the Tennessee product has been a revelation for a Chiefs group that has wanted to run extra energy ideas up entrance in opposition to two-excessive seems this season. The solely concern has been penalties; he has racked up 5 holding calls.

The rookie enjoying subsequent to Smith hasn’t been too unhealthy, both. Humphrey, a 3-yr starter at Oklahoma, has stepped into the NFL with out lacking a beat. I requested one NFL defensive coach what he thought after enjoying the Chiefs and he stated that Humphrey “seems like he is been within the NFL for a decade already.” That’s excessive reward for any rookie, not to mention a man with the kind of microscope Humphrey has on him blocking for Patrick Mahomes.

The tackles have struggled for Kansas City, however Humphrey and Smith are two of the very best draft picks the Chiefs have made since they drafted Mahomes in 2017.


Landry has been a stable go-rusher over his first three seasons within the league, producing about six sacks and 15 knockdowns per season. His potential to be the No. 1 man on an amazing protection was questionable, and with their go rush struggling final season, the Titans shelled out big money in free company for Bud Dupree to take over the first position.

Well, Dupree has been limited to two starts by damage and has only one sack. Landry has leveled up with out him. The 2018 second-rounder has already set profession highs in sacks (10) and knockdowns (19) with six common-season video games left. His 17 hurries lead the NFL.

He’s the newest Tennessee participant to have an amazing contract yr, leaving the Titans in a bind: Do they pay two go-rushers massive cash or let Landry observe Jack Conklin and Corey Davis out the door?

We have to get one Lions participant on this listing. Despite being drafted within the first spherical by Miami in 2017, Harris by no means obtained common time for the Dolphins and was traded to the Falcons for a seventh-spherical decide final yr. Finding his option to the Lions this season, Harris has been a a lot-improved participant. The main numbers do not blow you away, as he has solely 4 sacks and seven knockdowns, however he ranks eleventh within the league with 12 hurries and is nineteenth in pass rush win rate.

There aren’t many vivid spots in Detroit proper now, however the guys who’ve impressed are usually enjoying alongside the road of scrimmage. For a group that wishes to construct from the within out, that is promising to see.

Let’s observe the Lions participant by getting a Texans participant within the combine. Lopez, a sixth-spherical decide in April’s draft, has been spectacular as a two-down run defender for a group that quietly ranks tenth within the league in defensive DVOA. Houston has been above-common in energy conditions and boasts one of the league’s greatest defenses at stuffing runners for no gain or a loss; having a nostril deal with who can management the road of scrimmage makes that potential.

Lopez ranks seventh amongst inside linemen in ESPN’s run stop win rate statistic, making him a pleasant discover for a Texans group desperately missing younger expertise.

The Vikings appeared set on the inside this season with Sheldon Richardson, Dalvin Tomlinson and Michael Pierce, however with Pierce sidelined by damage since Week 4, Watts has stepped up and made the deal with spot his personal. Over his six video games as a starter, he has three sacks, a deal with for loss, 20 tackles and two pressured fumbles. He ranks 14th within the NFL in go rush win fee amongst tackles.

The Vikings moved Richardson to defensive finish for Sunday’s win in opposition to the Packers after Danielle Hunter went down for the season, so even after Pierce returns, Watts appears to have received a beginning job.

Where did this come from? Over his first 5 seasons within the NFL, Campbell was an honest inside linebacker who appeared to wrestle to translate his athletic expertise in protection. The 2016 Falcons draft decide allowed a passer ranking of 104 or better as the closest defender in protection in 4 of these first 5 seasons. After a season with the Cardinals noticed him lose enjoying time because the yr went alongside, the Packers scooped him up on a one-yr, $2 million deal this offseason.

Campbell has been good for the Packers at a place they’ve struggled to fill for years. In addition to being an above-common run defender, he has allowed a passer ranking of simply 74.2 as the closest defender in protection and leads all linebackers in protection with a minus-16.4 anticipated factors added (EPA) per play. The Packers rank seventh within the league in DVOA on throws to tight ends.

Campbell has been one of the league’s greatest bargains this season, and it would not be a shock if he earned a visit to the Pro Bowl.

I may have picked a 3rd Chiefs rookie right here and gone with Nick Bolton, however I need to as a substitute spotlight the development of this third-yr Colts defender. Indy let group chief Anthony Walker depart for the Browns this offseason, partly as a result of the Colts felt Okereke was able to be the person within the center. Playing as an each-down defender for the primary time in his profession, the 2019 third-rounder ranks within the high 10 in tackles, stops, run stops and hustle performs, that are when a participant runs 20 or extra yards to make a deal with.

The Colts struggled stopping massive performs earlier within the season, however Okereke has generated a good minus-3.1 EPA as the closest defender in protection. He’s not on Darius Leonard‘s degree, however Okereke has been an above-common beginning linebacker for the surging Colts.

I do not need to put many first-spherical picks on this listing as a result of it is troublesome for them to be underrated, however Terrell has a reputable case as one of the NFL’s best cornerbacks, full cease. The Falcons do not have him observe opposing receivers and have him principally keep on the left aspect of the protection, however we see his impression within the numbers.

They rank sixth within the league in QBR on passes thrown to the appropriate aspect of the sector and thirty first on throws in every single place else. Per the charting stats at Pro Football Reference, Terrell is permitting opponents to finish 50% of their passes whereas posting a 56.9 passer ranking, which ranks fifth amongst corners.

There’s not loads to like on protection for Atlanta, however Terrell and Foyesade Oluokun are holding up their finish of the discount.

The 2020 draft class was about as hit-or-miss because it will get for cornerbacks. First-rounders Jeff Okudah, CJ Henderson and Damon Arnette have struggled, however second-rounders Terrell and Trevon Diggs are two of essentially the most priceless corners in soccer, and Fulton seems to be proper behind them.

The 61st decide in that draft, Fulton moved into the beginning lineup after the Titans rebooted their secondary this offseason. He has allowed minus-10.9 EPA as the closest defender in protection this season, whereas quarterbacks concentrating on him in protection have posted a completion proportion 16.9% underneath expectation. That’s the second-greatest mark for corners with at the very least 100 protection snaps.

Fulton was on injured reserve with a hamstring damage, however the Titans had been delighted to welcome him back over the previous two weeks.

One extra defensive again from the 2020 draft? Sure. Dugger is nominally a security on paper, however he performs each security spots and additionally chips in a good quantity of the time as a slot nook. When NFL Next Gen Stats identifies him as a slot defender, he has allowed a passer ranking of simply 35.2 and generated 13.2 EPA for the Patriots’ protection, the latter of which ranks fourth within the NFL.

Bill Belichick finds a range of roles for the defender with tremendous measurables, however alongside fellow All-Underrated Team candidate Adrian Phillips, Dugger is perhaps greatest at shutting down opposing tight ends. He was among the many defenders who helped slow down Falcons star Kyle Pitts in final week’s shutout win over Atlanta.

Miami’s secondary has been a catastrophe this season, however Brian Flores has to be ok with what he has gotten from his rookie second-spherical decide. The Dolphins coach has had no qualms about lining up Holland as a free security or getting him within the field to assist out in opposition to the run.

Forced into the beginning lineup when Jason McCourty injured his foot in Week 4, Holland hasn’t seemed again, as he has defended six passes, picked up two sacks and recovered a fumble since. The Dolphins have felt the distinction: They’ve allowed a 53.1 QBR with Holland on the sector, with that determine rising all the best way to 80.1 with out him between the traces.

Life might be simpler enjoying alongside Derwin James, however with the star security wholesome this season, the Chargers have felt a distinction with out Adderley within the lineup. When he has been sidelined by damage or taking a breather, the Chargers have been almost 18 factors worse by QBR.

With coach Brandon Staley usually preferring to play two-deep coverages, Adderley has nearly all the time been enjoying the deep half, however he has been higher as a tackler when known as to take action. He has missed interceptions at instances, which is the one factor maintaining him from extra important nationwide consideration, however he is an thrilling younger participant on a Chargers protection seemingly full of thrilling younger gamers.


It’s a bit of a disgrace that two of McPherson’s three misses this season had been the tried sport winners against the Packers, as a result of the rookie fifth-spherical decide has in any other case been wonderful. He is 15-of-18 on discipline targets and 29-of-30 on additional factors.

After adjusting for problem, Football Outsiders pegs the Bengals because the ninth-best team on field goals and extra points, which McPherson has dealt with completely. Cincinnati can be third in factors added on kickoffs, the place he ranks eighth in common amongst common kickers.

At the dying, we snuck a Jets participant on the roster! Well, type of. By the methodology over at Puntalytics, Morstead ranked because the NFL’s third-greatest punter this season after adjusting for discipline place, sport state of affairs and EPA. The Jets responded to Morstead’s spectacular season by cutting the 35-year-old after the commerce deadline.

The longtime Saints punter signed with the Falcons earlier this week, which makes Atlanta the one group on this listing with three gamers. Given that groups such because the Ravens, Bills and Steelers rank on the backside of the listing in phrases of efficiency by their punters, it is arduous to think about Morstead could not have helped a extra aggressive group.


Most Popular